Supplements have become increasingly popular, but they remain largely unregulated in many countries. While there are situations where supplements can be beneficial, a food-first approach is often the best way to meet nutritional needs. Josie Porter, a registered dietitian with over a decade of experience in clinical settings, has witnessed the shift in how supplements are used—from addressing deficiencies to being part of wellness routines aimed at self-optimization.
“I’ve seen the stacks of supplements get longer over time,” Porter said. “It’s clear that the supplement industry is becoming more profitable and more popular.”
Despite the marketing efforts by supplement companies, many health claims lack strong scientific backing. The lack of regulation means that unless a product is third-party tested, it can be difficult to verify whether it contains what it says on the label. This could mean the product has more, less, or even none of the nutrients listed. Additionally, many supplements contain a mix of ingredients, which increases the risk of consuming more than necessary.
Porter shares three supplements she takes based on scientific evidence, emphasizing the importance of choosing supplements wisely.
Vitamin D
During the darker months of fall and winter, Porter, who lives in London, takes a vitamin D supplement. This aligns with recommendations from the UK’s National Health Service, as sunlight becomes limited during these times—a major source of vitamin D.
While few foods naturally contain vitamin D, sources like fatty fish, egg yolks, cheese, and fortified milk and cereal provide some of the richest amounts. Vitamin D supports the immune system and helps the body absorb calcium, which is crucial for bone health.
Omega-Three
Porter takes omega-three capsules when she hasn’t eaten oily fish recently. “I just take it as and when I need it,” she explained.
Omega-three fatty acids are found in oily fish such as salmon and sardines, as well as walnuts and chia seeds. They are linked to better heart and joint health, lower inflammation, and reduced blood pressure. Research suggests that eating oily fish is more beneficial than taking supplements for reaping the benefits of omega-three.
Collagen
When Porter injured a tendon, she turned to collagen supplements. She has also explored its use in skincare. She took her collagen as a powder stirred into liquid, but it’s also available in gel form, tablets, and gummies.
“The best options are marine or bovine collagen,” Porter said. There are vegan alternatives, but they typically contain collagen-boosting ingredients like vitamin C rather than actual collagen.
Collagen is a protein that the body produces less of as we age. It plays a key role in the structure of the skin. While the science is mixed, some studies suggest that collagen supplementation may improve skin hydration and elasticity, leading to a more youthful appearance.





