NSW Waratahs Face Crucial Crossroads After Disappointing Performance
The NSW Waratahs have found themselves in a precarious position following a lackluster performance against the Western Force, with coach Dan McKellar openly criticizing his team’s inability to assert dominance at the breakdown. The 20-17 loss has raised serious concerns about their chances of securing a spot in the Super Rugby Pacific finals.
McKellar was uncharacteristically blunt in his assessment of the team’s performance, pointing out that they were “bullied at the breakdown” throughout the match. This failure to control the ruck led to an overwhelming number of tackles—nearly 300—which ultimately left key attacking players like Max Jorgensen and Joseph-Aukuso Suaalii ineffective.
Key Players Struggled to Make an Impact
Despite being expected to be pivotal in the attack, both Jorgensen and Suaalii failed to make a significant contribution. Suaalii, who had returned from an eight-week hamstring injury, barely had any impact on the game. McKellar acknowledged the challenge of getting the ball into Jorgensen’s hands, highlighting the need for the team to reduce the number of tackles they are making.
“Stop making 300 tackles,” McKellar said when asked how Suaalii could be more effective. “I like the ball in Max’s hands. If you’re making 300 tackles, like how many did we make last week? 260? No one’s touching the ball.”
He added, “And when you’ve got 32 per cent territory, all you’re doing is defending and then trying to get out of your own end. So I can’t flick a switch and be like, ‘Su’, here’s space. You’ve got to earn that.”

A Challenging Road Ahead
The defeat leaves the Waratahs in eighth place on the table, and their path to the top-six playoffs looks increasingly difficult. They will need to win at least three of their remaining four games, including three away matches, to have any chance of qualifying.
McKellar admitted that he hasn’t even looked at the ladder, but he remains confident in the team’s potential. “I know when we’re at our best, as we’ve shown sporadically, we can beat anyone,” he said.
However, he also pointed out a concerning gap between the team’s best and worst performances. “But the gap between our best and not our best is too big at the moment.”
Looking Forward
With the pressure mounting, the Waratahs will need to regroup quickly if they want to salvage their season. McKellar emphasized the importance of consistency and discipline, especially in the breakdown area, where they were physically dominated by the Western Force.
The next few weeks will be crucial for the Waratahs as they aim to turn their fortunes around. With the right adjustments and a stronger showing in the upcoming matches, there is still hope for a late-season surge. However, without significant improvements, their chances of making the playoffs may be slipping away.






