The Good: Ivan Cleary Succession Plan on Track
The victory of the New South Wales (NSW) team in the first game of the State of Origin series is not only a significant boost for the Blues’ chances of reclaiming the title since 2024, but it also marks a step forward in the plan to bring Ivan Cleary into the fold. The current Penrith Panthers coach is expected to take over the Origin role in 2028 when his tenure at the Panthers concludes.
However, with Cleary committed to club responsibilities next year, NSW will need an interim coach for 2027 before transitioning to Cleary. The most logical choice for this role is the current coach, Laurie Daley, who could serve for another year before passing the reins to the four-time premiership winner.
For the NSWRL, having Daley lead the team to victory is essential to selling the idea of Cleary’s succession plan. At half-time during Wednesday night’s game, when the Blues were trailing and seemingly out of contention, some fans questioned whether a coach had ever been sacked mid-series. By the end of the match, history was made as Daley oversaw the greatest comeback in Origin history. This achievement ensures that the Cleary succession plan remains on track for at least the end of the series.
The Bad: Phil Gould in a Bizarre Post-Match Moment
Phil Gould, a well-known figure at Channel 9, is typically vocal and offers strong opinions on the game. However, after the dramatic moment where Kalyn Ponga received a send-off from referee Ashley Klein in Game 1 – one of the most memorable incidents in Origin history – Gould remained unusually quiet.
At full-time, Nine’s Origin host James Bracey asked Gould about the incident, questioning whether players see it as their responsibility to look after those they tackle. Gould responded with a direct refusal, stating, “James, I suggest you ask someone else rather than me. If you don’t mind. I’d like you to keep your job.” Bracey attempted to press further but was met with silence.
A television industry insider told Yahoo Sport Australia, “Nine aren’t going to tell Gus what to say and what not to say. Of course, they would have preferred him to comment on the incident, but there will be no repercussions. If it was a former player or coach just starting out in broadcasting, there may have been hell to pay, but Gus is an untouchable at Nine.”
The Ugly: NSW Players Facing the Axe Despite Win
Despite the dramatic win, the atmosphere in NSW might not remain positive for long. Questions are being raised about the performance of the Blues in the first half, where they trailed 20-0 at one point, and whether changes will be made to the team for Game 2.
Ethan Strange, a first-gamer, seems likely to lose his spot despite playing exceptionally well as Mitchell Moses’ replacement. Additionally, Casey McLean, who performed admirably when called into action after Tolu Koula’s night ended due to Ponga, may also miss selection if Latrell Mitchell is fit.
Daley indicated after the game that he would stick with his original lineup, including Moses at five-eighth and Koula on the wing, unless injury or suspension intervenes. While loyalty is admirable, and the saying goes that you should never change a winning side, Daley may reconsider after watching the game back.
Strange, in particular, appears to be perfectly suited for Origin, and leaving him out of what could be the series decider would be a bold decision.
