The Debate Over James Hird’s Potential Return to Essendon
The football world is buzzing with speculation following Essendon’s decision to part ways with Brad Scott. One of the central questions being asked is whether James Hird should return as the club’s coach. Hird, who has a 48-1-49 record as a coach, led the Bombers through one of their most challenging periods. Now 53, he recently made his case on Channel 9’s Footy Classified, claiming he is better equipped now after taking on a director of coaching role at Port Melbourne since last year.
Perspectives from Zero Hanger’s Editorial Team
Mark Stevens – YES
Mark Stevens is a strong advocate for Hird’s return. He believes that Essendon needs someone to help restore its identity and bring back the disillusioned fans. Hird, he argues, still carries an aura and is a natural leader. Stevens notes that Hird seems content and confident in his current role and has kept up with developments in the modern game. He also points out that Hird has worked closely with a sharp assistant like Mark McVeigh, which could help him adapt to the current landscape.
Stevens feels that Essendon needs a bold move to break the cycle and believes that a Bombers person is essential to regain the club’s DNA. He concludes that Hird deserves another shot at redemption.
Aidan Cellini – NO
Aidan Cellini disagrees, arguing that the idea of Hird returning has lingered for over a decade without ever dissipating. He believes that Essendon must move forward and explore new avenues rather than rehashing old names. Hird, he says, is not suitable for the role, especially given his lack of recent experience at the AFL level.
Cellini suggests that Hird should consider other clubs or work his way back into the league before making another pitch. He also highlights the availability of other qualified candidates, such as Ken Hinkley and John Longmire, who are ready to step into senior roles.
Jonty Ralphsmith – NO
Jonty Ralphsmith argues that Hird’s presence continues to cast doubt on other potential candidates. He believes that Essendon should quickly rule out Hird if he is not genuinely being considered, to ensure a fair and thorough selection process.
Ralphsmith points out that Hird has not coached at the AFL level for over a decade, during which the game has evolved significantly. He compares this to Nathan Buckley, who took a role at Geelong after only a few years away from the AFL. Ralphsmith also criticizes the notion that an Essendon person is necessary to restore the club’s spirit, citing examples like Chris Scott and Alastair Clarkson, who were not from the clubs they transformed.
He concludes that there is no objective reason to choose Hird over other proven coaches.
Harrison McIlwaine – NO
Harrison McIlwaine takes a more extreme stance, suggesting that Essendon should be liquidated if it considers Hird again. He calls the idea a desperate, nostalgia-driven move that would be backward for a professional organization.
McIlwaine argues that Hird has not been involved in the AFL landscape for years and was not up to the task of coaching an AFL side. He also points out that Hird led the Bombers to mediocre finishes despite having a better list than the current one. He urges the club to find a new leader, such as Craig McRae or Adam Kingsley, rather than relying on past glory.
Marcus Beeck – NO
Marcus Beeck is skeptical about the possibility of Hird’s return. He argues that Essendon appears to be an incestuous organization that only values internal candidates. This mindset, he says, extends to fans who believe that only an Essendon person can fix the club.
Beeck suggests that if Hird were to return and lead the Bombers to a premiership, it would be a Hollywood-worthy story. However, he believes the odds are stacked against such a scenario. He also criticizes the idea of bringing back a coach who was in charge during one of the darkest chapters in the club’s history.
Beeck concludes that Essendon’s president, Andrew Welsh, should look beyond the club’s bubble and consider the broader AFL landscape, where many are in disbelief at the idea of Hird’s return.





