San Francisco 49ers Face Critical Decision in 2026 NFL Draft
The San Francisco 49ers are at a crossroads as they head into the 2026 NFL draft. With a pressing need to bolster their pass rush, the team may be forced to explore trade options. Among the potential targets, the Pittsburgh Steelers could play a pivotal role.
According to Charles Robinson of Yahoo Sports, the Steelers have two pass rushers whose names are circulating in the trade market ahead of the draft. These players are Alex Highsmith and Nick Herbig. While both are being considered, it appears that Highsmith is more likely to be moved. Herbig, who has shown strong production while rotating with Highsmith and T.J. Watt, is seen as a valuable asset for the Steelers.
Highsmith, who will turn 29 in August, has two years remaining on his contract with a total scheduled base salary of $30 million. If he has a strong season in 2026, he may seek an extension that resets his salary and guarantees him additional years of income. However, with Herbig waiting in the wings and showing consistent performance, the Steelers are expected to entertain offers for Highsmith if the opportunity arises.
A high-level personnel executive noted, “I think they will trade one of them.” This statement suggests that the Steelers are open to moving at least one of their pass rushers, with Highsmith being the more probable candidate.
Potential Trade Target for the 49ers
Herbig has been previously mentioned as a possible target for the 49ers, but Robinson’s report indicates that Highsmith is viewed as the more available player. This is partly due to his age and contract status. The acquiring team would likely need to extend him beyond his current average annual value of $17 million. His contract expires after the 2027 season, making him a viable option for teams looking to add a proven pass rusher.
Despite the financial commitment, the 49ers should consider reaching out to the Steelers about acquiring Highsmith. Over the last four years, he has recorded 40 sacks and consistently pressures quarterbacks with a rate between 13 and 16 percent. His presence would provide the 49ers with a reliable pass rusher to complement Nick Bosa. Additionally, Highsmith could help maintain the effectiveness of the pass rush if Bosa is unavailable, which is a significant consideration given Bosa’s recent ACL injury.
Evaluating the Cost of the Trade
The exact cost for the 49ers to acquire Highsmith remains uncertain. The team currently has four fourth-round picks in this year’s draft, which could be used as part of the trade package. They might include one of these picks along with a Day 2 pick in 2027 to secure the deal. Depending on how the 49ers evaluate this year’s draft class, they may be willing to offer a second-round pick if they can recoup some draft capital through another trade.
Adding Highsmith would make strategic sense for the 49ers. He brings experience, proven performance, and the ability to contribute immediately. The team should be among those actively reaching out to the Steelers to negotiate a potential trade.
Conclusion
As the 2026 NFL draft approaches, the San Francisco 49ers must make critical decisions to address their pass rushing needs. A potential trade for Alex Highsmith could provide the team with a reliable and experienced pass rusher. While the financial implications are significant, the benefits of adding Highsmith could outweigh the costs. With the right strategy and negotiations, the 49ers may find themselves in a stronger position to compete in the upcoming season.
