Perth Bears’ Struggles and the Ongoing Debate
The ongoing challenges faced by the Perth Bears have once again taken center stage, with a recent episode of Nine’s 100% Footy reigniting the discussion about the club’s need for support. This comes just one week after a high-profile on-air clash between board member and Nine presenter James Bracey and former player Paul Gallen. The conversation has now extended to include Phil Gould, who has added his voice to the debate.
The segment began as a lighthearted look back at the previous incident, but quickly turned serious when Gallen brought up the topic of the Bears needing assistance in signing marquee players. His comments sparked a reaction from Gould, who had previously appeared disengaged during the earlier exchange between Bracey and Gallen.
Gallen was clear in his stance, stating that he did not believe the Bears deserved any salary cap dispensation or additional support. He questioned whether other teams would be upset if the Bears received such help, highlighting the competitive nature of the league.
Gould, however, took a firm position against the idea of providing assistance to the Bears. “Absolutely, I’m voting against that. What do you need help for? It’s not a charity mate, it’s a competition,” he said. His comments reflected a broader sentiment among some in the rugby league community that all teams should compete on equal footing.
Bracey explained the Bears’ situation, noting that they were seeking support after meeting with NRL CEO Peter V’landys and RLPA boss Clint Newton. He clarified that the request was not about adding a large sum to the salary cap, but rather about receiving some assistance with third-party agreements. However, Gould quickly countered this point, pointing out that clubs are not allowed to directly organize such arrangements with third parties.
This led to a brief but pointed exchange between Bracey and Gould, with Bracey attempting to shift the focus by making a playful comment about their respective roles as representatives of their teams. “I’m just flying the flag for my team Gus, just like you – we’ve all got conflicts here, there and everywhere,” he said.
The pressure on the Bears has only increased following Jarome Luai’s decision to sign with the PNG Chiefs for the 2028 season. This move has provided the Chiefs with a genuine marquee player, raising questions about how the Bears can compete in the future.
Michael Chammas, the chief executive of the PNG Chiefs, recently visited Australia to meet with several podcasters and Nine sports reporter Zac Bailey. This visit offered a glimpse into life in Port Moresby and allowed Chammas to speak with government officials, further highlighting the resources available to the new club.
Bracey was asked why the Bears had not taken a similar approach, but he provided a valid response. “He’s using [PNG] government money for that, we’re owned by the NRL,” he said. This distinction underscored the different financial structures and support systems available to the two clubs.
Allana Ferguson, who was present during the heated and at times awkward segment, assured viewers that the debate was legitimate. “I can’t believe people are questioning whether this is genuine or not – this is as genuine as it gets,” she said.
As the debate continues, it remains to be seen how the NRL will respond to the Bears’ requests for support. The situation highlights the challenges faced by new clubs in the league and the importance of finding a balance between competition and fairness. With the 2027 season approaching, the pressure on the Bears to secure top talent and establish themselves as a competitive force is mounting.
