Play the Kids
One of the most crucial steps for Collingwood is to give younger players a chance. Players like Ed Allan, Charlie West, and Will Hayes have shown enough promise to warrant sustained opportunities at the top level. The older players have done well to extend their careers beyond expectations, but it’s time to make tough decisions regarding players like Scott Pendlebury, Steele Sidebottom, Jeremy Howe, Tim Membrey, and Jack Crisp.
While Pendlebury’s recent Anzac Day Medal performance was impressive, it’s unrealistic to expect such form to be consistent at this stage of his career. Collingwood should not wait until these players are no longer effective before making necessary changes. They should thank them for their service and handle their departures with grace, similar to how the Australian Test side handled the exits of Shane Warne, Justin Langer, and Glenn McGrath.
Avoid Temptation with Lachie Neale
Collingwood should resist the temptation to sign Lachie Neale. Although he is in excellent form, acquiring him would likely involve a contract of two or more years, which would be a significant commitment for a player who is soon to turn 33. This move would be appropriate for a win-now club, but Collingwood is not in that position. The club’s list management team must recognize this and act accordingly.
Key Forward Hunt
Collingwood has not had a genuine key forward since Travis Cloke, who was known for his ability to score from close range. Since Cloke’s departure, the club has struggled to find a reliable goal kicker. Brody Mihocek, who was the closest thing to a key forward after Cloke left, has also departed. While the Pies have ruled out pursuing Ben King, they might consider targeting Mitch Lewis or Calsher Dear from Hawthorn. Lewis and Dear are both set to become free agents, and while the Hawks may prefer to keep the son of their 1991 Norm Smith Medallist, there could still be an opportunity for Collingwood.
Move the Daicos Boys
Nick Daicos needs to be moved back to his original role. His performance as a midfielder in his rookie year was instrumental in Collingwood’s rise up the ladder. However, his recent efficiency has been below par, and returning to his familiar role could help restore his form. This move would also allow his older brother, Josh, to return to his preferred position on the wing.
Beau in the Guts
Beau McCreery should be integrated into the team’s first-choice on-ball brigade. His relentless pursuit of the ball and willingness to take risks make him a valuable asset. He brings a different dynamic to the midfield, which is currently too one-paced. McCreery’s desire to play in the middle was evident after his Anzac Day performance, where he communicated his preference to the team.
Swing Blowtorch on Leppitsch
Justin Leppitsch appears to be responsible for the slow decline of the team. His move from assistant coach to general manager of talent and list strategy after the 2023 flag was unusual and came amid other changes. The club’s focus on bringing in experienced players rather than developing young talent has left a gap in their pathways. Clubs that repeat premierships typically have strong young players, but Collingwood sacrificed this opportunity in their quest for immediate competitiveness.
Poach a List Guru
Collingwood should leverage its status as a powerhouse to attract an experienced list manager. If Leppitsch remains, he will need support. Tim Lamb, who was instrumental in the Demons’ 2021 flag-winning list, and Adrian Caruso from Greater Western Sydney are both strong candidates. Their expertise in talent recognition and list construction could help Collingwood build a sustainable team.
Plan for Life After “Fly”
Craig McRae’s future with the club is uncertain. He has consistently stated that his coaching tenure is not indefinite, and he does not see himself as a long-term coach. Collingwood should prepare for his potential departure by identifying a successor. Hayden Skipworth, the current assistant, is seen as a potential candidate. Smart clubs have contingency plans in place, and Collingwood would be negligent if they do not prepare for McRae’s sudden exit, which is expected to happen sooner than many anticipate.
