The Struggles of Collingwood in 2026
What was once a defining trait of the Collingwood Football Club has become a source of concern in the 2026 season. Known for their ability to win close games, the Pies have found themselves struggling to finish matches decisively. This shift is particularly noticeable under the guidance of coach Craig McRae, who previously led the team to success with a strong closing game strategy.
The recent loss to the Western Bulldogs by four points highlights this issue. Despite being behind most of the match, Collingwood had opportunities to secure a victory. Similar situations occurred in games against Fremantle, Hawthorn, and Sydney, where the Pies fell short by narrow margins. This raises questions about whether opposing teams have uncovered weaknesses in McRae’s tactics.
A Decline in Performance
Looking back at previous seasons, Collingwood’s performance in tight games was impressive. In 2022, they were 9-3 in games decided by single-digit margins, and in their premiership year, they were 8-1. The following season, they maintained a strong record with 6-2-1, but last year saw a drop to 3-4. This year, the team is currently 1-1-3, and their struggles in close games threaten their position in the top 10, even with the Wildcard Round.
The Pies’ efficiency in high-pressure moments has been a hallmark of their success, but recent performances have shown costly errors that are out of character. Against the Fremantle Dockers, defensive lapses in the final term allowed Jye Amiss and Matthew Johnson to score go-ahead goals. An unforced error from Billy Frampton in the defensive-50 area led to Johnson capitalizing on the Pies’ mistake during the Gather Round.
Missed Opportunities
Collingwood’s performance against the Hawthorn Hawks was arguably one of their best of the season, yet they still ended up sharing the points. In the final play of the game, key forward Dan McStay had a chance to get the ball over the boundary line. Instead, Tom Barrass intercepted the ball in a move reminiscent of a primary school ‘Jack in the Pack’ grab. This led to a sloppy double play from captain Darcy Moore, which resulted in a dropped mark and a free-kick against, ultimately leading to a draw.
A similar situation occurred against the Sydney Swans, who were beaten comfortably until the end of the third term. Rushed forward thrusts and a lack of composure allowed the Swans to hang on to their lead. Another opportunity lost for the Pies.
Challenges Against the Bulldogs
The latest match against the undermanned Western Bulldogs further exposed Collingwood’s issues. Their centre ball-up work was arguably their worst of the season, and they struggled to gain momentum from the start. While a final term of 5.5 points was a positive sign, their inefficiencies were the deciding factor in the outcome. Darcy Cameron’s hack kick forward, with just over a minute left on the clock, symbolized the Pies’ inability to handle pressure.
In previous years, Collingwood would work the ball through by hand until a clearer kick or option became available. Although Michael Sellwood’s mark should not be overlooked, as it resembled a Leo Barry moment, the Pies have typically avoided such situations, giving themselves a chance to win.
McRae’s Perspective
Despite the challenges, McRae remains optimistic, as is his nature. He chose to focus on the positives after the match, acknowledging the progress made while also recognizing the areas that need improvement. However, the growing noise from outside sources suggests that the Pies are heading towards a critical juncture.
The team’s performance, much like their ability to close out matches, has regressed in 2026. This regression has highlighted cracks in a side that is searching for answers. As the season progresses, it will be crucial for Collingwood to address these issues and regain their former dominance in close games.
