Essendon’s struggles this season have not improved with a new coach, as the Bombers were comfortably defeated by West Coast in Perth on Sunday night. The Eagles maintained a lead of up to 49 points in the fourth quarter before the margin was reduced to 30 at the final siren.

The past week has been challenging for Essendon, as they announced the sacking of coach Brad Scott on Tuesday. Assistant coach Ben Jacobs and welfare boss Ben Robbins followed suit on Friday, resigning after Scott.
Additionally, the team suffered five player injuries during the match against Richmond, including captain Andrew McGrath, who sustained a broken jaw.
Dean Solomon, the interim coach, faced a difficult start to his role, as his team was outplayed by West Coast. However, former Essendon coach James Hird, who is interested in returning to the position in 2027, does not blame Solomon for the loss.
“I thought they had a good 10 minutes in the second quarter, but after that, the Eagles took control,” Hird said in an interview with Nine’s Footy Furnace.
He acknowledged the challenges Solomon faced, noting that he was appointed just four days ago and had limited time to make changes. Additionally, two key staff members left, and the team lost five experienced players to injury from the previous game.
Hird believes the performance was not their best, but he is hopeful that Solomon will be able to prepare thoroughly for the upcoming game against Carlton.
Key Challenges Faced by Essendon
- The team’s poor performance was highlighted by their inability to maintain defensive accountability.
- In the third quarter, West Coast demonstrated superior ball movement, kicking five goals to two, which widened the gap significantly.
- A specific play in the third quarter saw West Coast receive a free kick 50 meters from goal, leading to an easy goal for Tom McCarthy.
Hird criticized the Bombers’ defensive approach, pointing out that the lack of accountability allowed West Coast to score so easily. He emphasized that the defense failed to man up properly, leaving the goal open.
“Look how much time they have to man up and then at the top of your screen there, that’s just unacceptable,” Hird said. “Whether there should be a forward rolling up, I know there’s a lot of players back, but that’s unacceptable.”
Positive Developments Elsewhere
While Essendon continues to face challenges, another team under a caretaker coach has shown significant improvement. Carlton has won three consecutive games under Josh Fraser, and they are set to take on the Bombers on Sunday night.
This contrast highlights the importance of leadership and preparation in football. As Essendon looks to recover, the focus will be on how Dean Solomon can implement a solid game plan and rebuild the team’s confidence.

With a week ahead of them, Solomon has the opportunity to assess the team’s needs and make necessary adjustments. The upcoming match against Carlton could serve as a turning point for Essendon, providing a chance to regain momentum and show progress under his guidance.






